In partnership with
Hey All-Stars and Brand-Builders,
This week brought a wave of developments that every student-athlete and parent needs to understand. From breakthrough compliance data that reveals how the NIL market really works, to contract traps that could cost you your future earnings, the landscape continues to mature.
Welcome back to The Helm, your compass through the evolving NIL waters.
The $15 Million Reality Check: What Rejected Deals Reveal
The College Sports Commission dropped a bombshell report this week, revealing that over 500 NIL deals worth nearly $15 million were rejected, primarily for lacking a "valid business purpose" or failing to demonstrate actual NIL activation. This represents about 3% of all submitted deals, and it tells us something critical: the enforcement era is here.
The good news? 97% of deals still get approved, and the average cleared deal is worth approximately $7,000. But here's what stood out: athletes with professional representation earn a little more than 2x more than those without.
🧭 Navigator Insight: The CSC data proves that legitimate NIL deals require documentation. If you can't explain exactly how your name, image, or likeness will be used and prove it happened, your deal won't survive scrutiny. This is why we've partnered with SquarePact for AI-powered contract analysis.
Another crucial finding: 52% of NIL deals are now cleared within 24 hours when properly documented. The system isn't designed to slow you down, it's designed to filter out deals that don't have genuine commercial substance.
Your Action Items:
✓ Document every deliverable in writing before signing
✓ Consider working with an agent or advisor, the 2x earnings premium often exceeds their fees
✓ Keep records of all promotional activities (posts, appearances, content)
The Contract Trap: When "Non-Exclusive" Becomes a Cage
Two high-profile cases this week exposed a dangerous trend: revenue-sharing contracts being weaponized to trap athletes.
At Washington, a quarterback's transfer was blocked after he signed a revenue-sharing NIL contract with exclusive rights clauses. At Duke, freshman sensation Darian Mensah entered the transfer portal only to discover his school claims exclusive NIL rights under a two-year deal, potentially forcing a buyout or legal battle.
🚨 Warning: One NIL attorney described these arrangements as "like the mafia", handshake promises that turn into expensive handcuffs. The attorney noted he now routinely rewrites "exclusive" clauses to "non-exclusive" in revenue-sharing agreements, and schools across the ACC and SEC have quietly accepted these changes to avoid disputes.
🏈 Coach's Corner: Before you sign any revenue-sharing agreement, ask these questions:
Can I transfer without a buyout?
What happens if I want to pursue other NIL opportunities?
Who owns my likeness rights after I leave?
If you don't like the answers, or can't get clear answers, don't sign.
Protection Protocol:
✓ Have every contract reviewed by an independent attorney before signing
✓ Negotiate explicit transfer provisions and buyout terms upfront
✓ Avoid multi-year exclusive arrangements unless the compensation is truly exceptional
The Silent Majority: Olympic & Women's Sports Are Winning
Here's the story the headlines miss: 44% of all athletes with cleared NIL deals compete in sports outside football and men's basketball. The CSC data shows NIL activity spanning 40+ NCAA disciplines: from women's beach volleyball to lacrosse to golf.
This week alone, notable deals emerged for athletes across multiple sports: Ryann Genest (USF beach volleyball) partnered with Bloom Nutrition, Sydney Manning (Penn State lacrosse) signed with Mission, and Shannon Kennedy (Michigan State golf) secured a deal with MSU Federal Credit Union.
🧭 Navigator Truth: If you're in a "non-revenue" sport, stop thinking of yourself as a secondary market. You ARE the market with less competition for local brand partnerships and community sponsorships. D2 athletes are finding untapped local opportunities where deals average under $2K, but offer genuine community connections and authentic brand building.
The Opportunity:
✓ Target local businesses in your community… they're often overlooked by "big name" athletes
✓ Build authentic content around your sport's unique story and training demands
✓ Position yourself as a niche expert, specialization creates premium value
The $1.7 Billion Frontier: High School NIL Explodes
Under Armour made history this week by launching the "Click Clack" NIL class the first major corporate program specifically targeting high school athletes. Participants receive endorsement training, gear sponsorships, and early brand-building support.
This follows reports identifying a $1.7 billion market opportunity awaiting high school athletes as more states permit NIL activity for minors. The high school NIL frontier represents the next major expansion of the ecosystem and athletes who prepare now will have significant advantages.
📋 For High School Athletes:
Check your state's high school NIL rules - regulations vary dramatically by state
Start building your social media presence now - authentic audiences take time to grow
Document your athletic journey - training videos, achievements, and personal story content creates value
Involve parents early - contracts involving minors require extra legal scrutiny
👨👩👧 For Parents:
Understand that early NIL activity can impact college recruiting conversations
Research programs that offer endorsement training and brand-building education
Be cautious of deals that seem "too good to be true" early exploitation is a real risk
The $3.5 Million Crackdown: When Loopholes Close
The College Sports Commission's crackdown on multimedia rights (MMR) partner deals this week wasn't theoretical it was triggered by a reported $3.5 million guarantee to LSU quarterback Brendan Sorsby through Playfly Sports, the school's MMR partner.
The result? The CSC issued enforcement notices to 20 NCAA Division I schools about potential violations from third-party deals used as transfer incentives. New guidance now requires that contracts with associated entities must specify exactly how an athlete's NIL will be used, not merely promise future activation.
⚠️ What This Means: If you're offered a deal through a school's MMR partner or associated entity, demand specifics: What exactly will you do? When? How will your NIL be activated? "We'll figure it out later" is no longer acceptable, and could put your deal at risk of rejection.
The broader lesson? The gray areas are shrinking. As revenue-sharing models roll out, the distinction between legitimate NIL deals and pay-for-play is becoming the central compliance battleground. Athletes who understand this shift—and structure their deals accordingly—will thrive. Those who don't will find their agreements rejected or unwound.
🚨 Partnership Alert: NIL Navigator x SquarePact 🚨
NIL contracts can be packed with confusing fine print. With SquarePact (powered by Actualization.ai), you can upload your deal and get AI-powered insights in minutes. See key terms, obligations, and red flags in plain English before you sign.
Get your first contract analyzed: [email protected]
The Final Whistle
This week's developments paint a clear picture: the NIL era is maturing from wild west to regulated marketplace. Compliance mechanisms are working. Deal quality matters more than deal volume. And the athletes who approach NIL strategically with proper documentation, professional representation, and long-term vision are the ones capturing real value.
The Key Takeaways:
Documentation is destiny - the CSC is rejecting $15M in deals that can't prove legitimate business purpose
Read before you sign - exclusive clauses in revenue-sharing deals are becoming transfer traps
Your sport has value - 44% of NIL athletes are outside football and men's basketball
Start early, prepare wisely - the high school NIL market is opening, but so are the risks
Get specifics in writing - vague "future activation" promises won't survive compliance review
The NIL Navigator exists to be your compass through this complexity. When rules change, when opportunities emerge, when pitfalls appear, we're here to help you navigate, adapt, and build something that lasts.
Stay strategic. Stay authentic. Stay ready.
Game on,
The NIL Navigator Team
💬 Pay it forward: Share this newsletter with an athlete, coach, or parent who wants to level up their NIL game
The Helm Newsletter is published weekly for athletes, parents, and coaches navigating the modern student-athlete sports landscape. Have a topic suggestion or question? Reach out to us at [email protected]
Disclaimer: NIL Navigator provides general information and education, not legal advice. For legal matters, please consult a qualified attorney.
One Simple Scoop For Better Health
The best healthy habits aren't complicated. AG1 Next Gen helps support gut health and fill common nutrient gaps with one daily scoop. It's one easy routine that fits into real life and keeps your health on track all day long. Start your mornings with AG1 and keep momentum on your side.
© 2025 The Helm Sports Media. All rights reserved.