Hey All-Stars and Brand-Builders,
Happy New Year! As we kick off 2026, the NIL landscape continues to evolve at breakneck speed. Revenue-sharing is now reality, high school NIL has expanded to 45+ states, and the contracts athletes are signing look more like professional agreements than ever before. This week's edition delivers the strategic intelligence you need to navigate these changes from contract red flags that could cost you millions to the mental health considerations that will determine your long-term success.
Welcome back to The Helm, where we turn complex developments into your competitive advantage.
Contract Red Flags: The Revenue-Sharing Agreement Trap
The New Reality: Since July, schools have been able to pay athletes directly through revenue-sharing agreements, but here's what the headlines don't tell you: these contracts are increasingly sophisticated, and they're designed to protect schools, not athletes.
Recent reports reveal that Big Ten schools are asking athletes to sign over their NIL rights, permit universities to sub-license those rights to "any and all third parties," and surrender legal claims to employee status.Β
The fine print matters more than ever.
β οΈ CRITICAL WARNING: Contract Clauses to Watch
"Termination for Convenience" - Schools can end your deal anytime; you can't
Performance-Based Triggers - Pay stops if you're benched, redshirted, or injured
Transfer Penalties - Buyout clauses requiring repayment if you enter the portal
Extended Rights Grants - Licensing your name, voice, and likeness beyond graduation
Exclusivity Restrictions - Limiting your ability to work with competing brands
The Wisconsin-Miami Lesson: The recent lawsuit involving Wisconsin and Miami over player Xavier Lucas demonstrates just how serious contract enforcement has become. Wisconsin is pursuing legal action over what it calls a "binding two-year NIL agreement," claiming tampering and contract interference. This isn't hypothetical, athletes are now bound by contracts that programs WILL ENFORCE.
π§ Navigator Protection Strategy
Get independent legal review before signing any revenue-sharing agreement
Document everything - every appearance, post, and service you provide
Understand market value - unrealistic deals trigger βNIL Goβ investigations
Watch for conflicts - new school agreements may violate existing third-party deals
Keep copies of everything - contracts, communications, and payment records
High School NIL Expansion: 45 States and Counting
The Big Picture: As of late 2025, at least 45 states plus Washington D.C. now allow some form of high school NIL. This rapid expansion means the majority of high school athletes in America can now monetize their name, image, and likeness, but the rules vary dramatically by state.
State-by-State Status Overview
β Permitted (40+ States) | β οΈ Restricted | π« Prohibited |
California, Florida, Georgia, Virginia, Colorado, Arizona, and 35+ others allow NIL with standard restrictions | Texas (17+ only, deferred payment), Arkansas, Mississippi, Missouri (letter of intent required) | Alabama, Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, Hawaii still prohibit high school NIL |
Universal Restrictions (Almost Everywhere): Even in permitted states, certain rules apply universally. Athletes cannot:
Use school logos, uniforms, or trademarks in NIL deals.Β
Partnerships with alcohol, tobacco, gambling, and adult content are prohibited.
Performance-based incentives and pay-for-play arrangements remain banned.
The Reporting Gap: Only five states: Arizona, Delaware, Georgia, Pennsylvania, and Virginia, specifically require athletes to report NIL deals to school administrators. Georgia allows the most time (seven days), while other states have no formal reporting requirements. This inconsistency creates compliance risks when transitioning to college.
High School NIL & Your College Future: The Critical Connection
Here's what most families miss: Your high school NIL decisions don't exist in a vacuum. Universities are now explicitly vetting incoming athletes' NIL histories, and what you do at 16 or 17 can directly impact your college eligibility and institutional risk assessment.
π What College Compliance Offices Are Looking For
State association compliance: Did your high school deals follow your state's rules?
Contract terms: Are existing deals structured properly? Will they conflict with school agreements?
Exclusivity clauses: Do any high school deals restrict your ability to sign with school sponsors?
Brand alignment: Have you partnered with brands that could create PR issues?
Documentation: Can you prove all deals were legitimate and properly executed?
π§ Coach's Corner: The revenue-sharing era has created six and seven-figure valuations for top football recruits. But this also means increased scrutiny. What a student-athlete did with NIL in high school can affect eligibility and institutional risk in 2026. Start building clean documentation habits now.
The Revenue-Sharing Reality: Understanding the True Market
Cap? What Cap? The House v. NCAA settlement established a $20.5 million annual cap on direct revenue-sharing payments to athletes. In theory, this creates a level playing field. In practice, programs have already found workarounds that are reshaping competitive balance.
How Schools Are Operating Above the Cap:
Frontloading: Collectives rushed to beat implementation by frontloading deals before July 2025. Texas Tech spent $28 million on its roster, including $7 million on its defensive line alone.
Third-Party Partnerships: Schools like Penn State and LSU have partnered with apparel sponsors and multimedia rights holders to facilitate NIL deals outside the cap.
In-House Agencies: Ohio State created Buckeye Sports Group to manage revenue-sharing and NIL. Other schools are building similar infrastructure to maximize opportunities.
Coach Guarantees: LSU reportedly guaranteed new coach Lane Kiffin $25 million annually for roster building. This was separate from revenue-sharing.
π§ Navigator Insight: The Real Numbers
In early December Notre Dame AD Pete Bevacqua put it bluntly: "The numbers you're hearing and the numbers we know that are out there don't compute with the cap number".Β When evaluating programs, don't just ask about their revenue-sharing allocation, ask about their total roster investment, including third-party NIL opportunities, apparel partnerships, and collective infrastructure.
Reported Program Investments: Ohio State (~$35M), Texas Tech ($28M+), LSU ($25M guaranteed for coach), multiple SEC schools committing $25-30M annually.
The Parity Paradox: Money Doesn't Guarantee Championships
Here's the most underreported story in college athletics: NIL isn't creating the dynasty dominance everyone predicted. Instead, it's creating chaos, and opportunity for smart programs and athletes who understand the new dynamics.
The Evidence:
Texas: Spent an estimated $18+ million and suffered a disappointing playoff fade. Boosters are asking hard questions.
Michigan: Post-championship struggles despite robust NIL funding have accelerated coaching hot seat discussions.
Vanderbilt: Went from 2-10 to legitimate contender through strategic NIL allocation and undervalued portal targets.
π§ Coach's Corner: People thought the old model was complex: recruiting rankings + facilities + coaching = success. The new model is blowing lids!: strategic NIL allocation + portal management + player development + coaching chemistry = possible success? Money matters, but how a school spends it matters more.
What This Means for Athletes:
Research program NIL strategy before committing, big budget doesn't guarantee wins or development
Mid-major opportunities are more attractive than ever if programs demonstrate smart resource management
Coaching stability is more precarious - elevated expectations mean faster turnover
Culture and development matter as much as compensation when choosing programs
Let's have a real conversation that often gets lost in the NIL gold rush: the mental health implications of this new landscape. The opportunities are real, but so are the pressures, and smart athletes build sustainable careers by addressing both.
The Research Is Clear: Recent studies show that NIL has introduced new stressors for student-athletes, including time management challenges when balancing academic responsibilities, training schedules, and NIL obligations. Pressures to maintain a public image can foster feelings of inadequacy and unhealthy comparisons among peers, while disparities in NIL opportunities among teammates can create unique tensions and feelings of isolation.
Bijan Robinson's Warning: Atlanta Falcons running back Bijan Robinson recently spoke publicly about his struggles with NIL pressure during his time at Texas: "It became really stressful for me to live with the brand news... I got school, I got to study for tests, I got practice... There was a point where I wasn't talking to my mom. I was gonna talk to her like, once every three weeks. And it was because I was just too tired mentally and physically."
Withdrawing from family and friends due to exhaustion
Constant anxiety about social media performance and engagement
Comparing yourself negatively to teammates' NIL success
Feeling like your identity is tied entirely to your athletic and brand performance
Sacrificing sleep, recovery, or academic performance for NIL obligations
Feeling pressure to maintain a "curated" public image that doesn't reflect your true self
Set boundaries: Not every opportunity is worth taking. Learn to say no to deals that don't align with your values or schedule.
Prioritize relationships: Family and close friends shouldn't be casualties of your success. Schedule time for the people who matter.
Protect your rest: Recovery isn't optional. Overcommitment to NIL activities leads to exhaustion that hurts both performance and mental health.
Stay authentic: Build a brand that reflects who you actually are. The dissonance between your public image and internal experience is exhausting.
Seek support: Mental health resources exist for a reason. Using them is a sign of strength, not weakness.
π§ Navigator Truth: The athletes who will thrive in this era aren't just the ones who maximize short-term earnings, they're the ones who build sustainable careers by protecting their mental health, maintaining relationships, and staying grounded in who they are beyond athletics. Your wellbeing is your most valuable asset.
If you feel the pressure is becoming too much, please reach out to [email protected] we have resources to help with lowering the pressure. Please in the subject line be sure to type in βToo Muchβ.
We have a special game-changing collaboration with actualization.ai and their tool: SquarePact, the platform that makes contracts simple.
NIL contracts can be packed with confusing fine print, but with SquarePact, you can upload your deal and get NIL-specific AI-powered insights in minutes. See key terms, obligations, and red flags in plain English so you can make smarter decisions before you sign.
Get your first contract analyzed by emailing [email protected]Β
The Final Whistle: Your 2026 Playbook
As we enter 2026, the NIL landscape has never been more complex, or more full of opportunity for those who understand it. The revenue-sharing era is here, high school NIL has expanded nationwide, and the contracts athletes sign are more sophisticated than ever.
Your Key Takeaways:
Contract literacy is essential. Revenue-sharing agreements are legally binding documents with real consequences. Get professional review.
High school NIL decisions matter. What you do now affects your college eligibility. Build clean documentation habits early.
The cap isn't the whole picture. When evaluating programs, ask about total roster investment, not just revenue-sharing allocation.
Money doesn't equal success. Strategic NIL allocation beats lavish spending. Focus on programs with smart resource management.
Mental health is your foundation. Sustainable success requires protecting your wellbeing. Set boundaries and stay authentic.
NIL Navigator exists to be your compass through this complexity. When rules change, when contracts confuse, when opportunities shiftβwe're here to help you navigate, adapt, and ultimately dominate.
Stay strategic. Stay informed. Stay protected.
Game on, The NIL Navigator Team
π¬ Pay it forward: Share this newsletter with an athlete, coach, or parent who wants to level up their NIL game
The Helm Newsletter is published weekly for athletes, parents, and coaches navigating the modern student-athlete sports landscape. Have a topic suggestion or question? Reach out to us at [email protected]
Disclaimer: NIL Navigator provides general information and education, not legal advice. For legal matters, please consult a qualified attorney.
AI-native CRM
βWhen I first opened Attio, I instantly got the feeling this was the next generation of CRM.β
β Margaret Shen, Head of GTM at Modal
Attio is the AI-native CRM for modern teams. With automatic enrichment, call intelligence, AI agents, flexible workflows and more, Attio works for any business and only takes minutes to set up.
Join industry leaders like Granola, Taskrabbit, Flatfile and more.
Β© 2025 The Helm Sports Media. All rights reserved.